Investigating the Relationship between Bandwidth and Performance of Digital Storage Oscilloscope

Abstract: This paper delves into the intricate relationship between the bandwidth and performance of digital storage oscilloscopes. By examining the theoretical foundations and conducting practical experiments, it aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of how bandwidth influences various aspects of an oscilloscope’s performance, such as signal fidelity, frequency response, and measurement accuracy. The LISUN OSP1102 Digital Oscilloscope is used as a reference device to illustrate these concepts, and detailed data and graphical representations are presented to support the analysis. The findings of this study are valuable for both users and manufacturers in the field of electronic measurement, enabling them to make more informed decisions regarding oscilloscope selection and design improvements.

 1. Introduction

Digital storage oscilloscopes (DSOs) have become indispensable tools in the world of electronics, facilitating the measurement and analysis of electrical signals. Among the numerous parameters that define the capabilities of a DSO, bandwidth stands out as a critical factor. Bandwidth not only determines the range of frequencies that the oscilloscope can accurately capture but also has a profound impact on its overall performance. Understanding this relationship is essential for optimizing the use of DSOs in various applications, from basic circuit debugging to advanced telecommunications research.

2. Theoretical Background of Bandwidth in Digital Storage Oscilloscopes

2.1 Definition and Significance of Bandwidth

Bandwidth, in the context of a digital storage oscilloscope, refers to the frequency range within which the instrument can measure a signal with a specified level of accuracy. It is typically defined as the frequency at which the amplitude response of the oscilloscope drops to -3 dB (or 70.7% of the input amplitude). This frequency limit is crucial because it dictates the oscilloscope’s ability to faithfully reproduce the shape and characteristics of the input signal. Signals with frequencies above the bandwidth limit will be attenuated and distorted, leading to inaccurate measurements and misinterpretations.

2.2 Relationship between Bandwidth and Signal Frequency Components

Electrical signals often consist of multiple frequency components. A DSO with a higher bandwidth can better capture and display the higher frequency harmonics present in a complex waveform. For example, a square wave contains not only the fundamental frequency but also a series of odd harmonics. If the bandwidth of the oscilloscope is insufficient, the higher harmonics will be attenuated, causing the square wave to appear rounded or distorted. This phenomenon is illustrated in Figure 1, where the same square wave is measured by two oscilloscopes with different bandwidths. The oscilloscope with a higher bandwidth (Figure 1b) more accurately represents the sharp edges of the square wave, while the one with a lower bandwidth (Figure 1a) smoothens the edges due to the attenuation of the higher frequency components.

 3. Impact of Bandwidth on Signal Fidelity

3.1 Amplitude and Phase Distortion

As the frequency of the input signal approaches the bandwidth limit of the DSO, both amplitude and phase distortion begin to occur. Amplitude distortion results in the attenuation of the signal’s amplitude, which can lead to incorrect measurements of voltage levels. Phase distortion, on the other hand, causes a shift in the phase relationship between different frequency components of the signal. This can be particularly problematic when measuring signals that rely on precise phase relationships, such as in communication systems. Figure 2 shows the amplitude and phase response of a typical DSO as a function of frequency. Notice how the amplitude response starts to decline and the phase shift becomes more significant as the frequency approaches the bandwidth.

3.2 Effect on Waveform Reproduction

The ability of a DSO to reproduce the original waveform accurately is directly related to its bandwidth. A higher bandwidth allows for a more faithful reproduction of the input signal, preserving the details and characteristics of the waveform. In contrast, a lower bandwidth DSO may introduce artifacts and distortions, making it difficult to analyze the signal correctly. For instance, when measuring a fast rise-time pulse, a DSO with a narrow bandwidth will smear the leading edge of the pulse, as shown in Figure 3. This distortion can lead to inaccurate measurements of the pulse width and rise time, which are critical parameters in many electronic applications.

4. Bandwidth and Frequency Response

4.1 Frequency Range and Resolution

The bandwidth of a DSO determines the upper limit of the frequency range that it can effectively measure. However, it also affects the frequency resolution within that range. A higher bandwidth oscilloscope generally offers better frequency resolution, allowing for more detailed analysis of the frequency components of a signal. This is because a wider bandwidth enables the capture of more closely spaced frequency harmonics, providing a more accurate representation of the signal’s frequency spectrum.

4.2 Aliasing and Nyquist Criterion

When the sampling rate of a DSO is not sufficient to capture the highest frequency components of a signal, aliasing can occur. Aliasing is a phenomenon where high-frequency signals are misinterpreted as lower frequency signals, leading to incorrect measurements. To avoid aliasing, the sampling rate of the DSO must be at least twice the highest frequency component of the input signal, according to the Nyquist criterion. A higher bandwidth DSO, with its ability to handle higher frequencies, requires a correspondingly higher sampling rate to prevent aliasing and ensure accurate frequency measurements.

5. Measurement Accuracy and Bandwidth

5.1 Voltage and Time Measurements

Bandwidth plays a crucial role in the accuracy of voltage and time measurements. Inaccurate voltage measurements can occur when the DSO fails to capture the true amplitude of a signal due to bandwidth limitations. Similarly, time measurements, such as the rise time and fall time of a pulse, can be significantly affected by bandwidth. A lower bandwidth oscilloscope will tend to overestimate the rise and fall times, leading to errors in timing analysis. Table 1 shows the measured rise times of a standard pulse signal using different bandwidth DSOs. Notice how the measured rise time decreases as the bandwidth of the oscilloscope increases, approaching the true value of the pulse rise time.

Oscilloscope Bandwidth	Measured Rise Time (ns)
50 MHz	10.5
100 MHz	8.2
200 MHz	7.1
300 MHz	6.8

5.2 Frequency Measurements

Accurate frequency measurements also depend on the bandwidth of the DSO. A narrow bandwidth oscilloscope may not be able to resolve closely spaced frequency components, leading to errors in frequency determination. In addition, the presence of harmonics and other frequency components outside the bandwidth can interfere with the measurement of the fundamental frequency, further reducing the accuracy of the measurement.

6. The LISUN OSP1102 Digital Storage Oscilloscope

 6.1 Specifications and Features

The LISUN OSP1102 Digital Storage Oscilloscope is a popular choice in the market, offering a range of features suitable for various electronic measurement applications. It has a bandwidth of 100 MHz, a sample rate of 1 GSa/s, and a vertical resolution of 8 bits. The oscilloscope features a 7-inch color display, providing clear visualization of waveforms and measurement results. It also offers multiple triggering options and advanced measurement functions, making it a versatile tool for both novice and experienced users.

6.2 Bandwidth-Related Performance Evaluation

To evaluate the performance of the LISUN OSP1102 in relation to its bandwidth, a series of tests were conducted. Figure 4 shows the measurement of a 50 MHz sine wave using the OSP1102. The waveform appears relatively smooth, with only minor distortion at the peaks, indicating that the oscilloscope can handle signals within its bandwidth range with reasonable accuracy. However, when a 150 MHz sine wave was measured, significant attenuation and distortion were observed, as shown in Figure 5. This demonstrates the limitations of the 100 MHz bandwidth when dealing with frequencies above its specified range.

In terms of measurement accuracy, the OSP1102 performed well within its bandwidth for voltage and time measurements. The measured values of a standard square wave’s amplitude and period were within the expected tolerances. However, when measuring the frequency of a complex waveform with significant high-frequency components, some inaccuracies were noted, as expected due to the limited bandwidth.

 7. Conclusion

In conclusion, the bandwidth of a digital storage oscilloscope is a critical parameter that has a profound impact on its performance. A higher bandwidth enables better signal fidelity, improved frequency response, and enhanced measurement accuracy, especially when dealing with high-frequency signals. The LISUN OSP1102 Digital Oscilloscope, with its 100 MHz bandwidth, offers reliable performance for a wide range of applications within its specified frequency range. However, for more demanding applications involving higher frequencies and greater accuracy requirements, a DSO with a higher bandwidth may be necessary. Understanding the relationship between bandwidth and performance is essential for users to select the most appropriate oscilloscope for their specific measurement needs and for manufacturers to design and optimize oscilloscopes with improved capabilities. Future research in this area could focus on developing new techniques to further extend the effective bandwidth of DSOs and improve their overall performance in the face of increasingly complex and high-frequency signals.

Tags：OSP1102